32nd VTRMC, 2010, Solutions

  1. It is easily checked that 101 is a prime number (divide 101 by the primes whose square is less than 101, i.e. the primes ≤7). Therefore for 1≤r≤100, we may choose a positive integer q such that rq≡1 mod 101. Since (I + A + ... + A100)(I - A) = I - A101, we see that A101 = I, in particular A is invertible with inverse A100. Suppose 1 < n≤100 and set r = 101 - n. Then 1≤r≤100 and An + ... + A100 is invertible if and only if I + ... + Ar-1 is invertible. We can think of I + ... + Ar-1 as (I - Ar)/(I - A), which should have inverse (I - A)/(I - Ar). However A = (Ar)q and so (I - A)/(I - Ar) = I + Ar + ... + (Ar)q-1. It is easily checked that

    (I + ... + Ar-1)(I + Ar + ... + (Ar)q-1) = I.

    It follows that An + ... + A100 is invertible for all positive integers n≤100. We conclude that An + ... + A100 has determinant ±1 for all positive integers n < 100.

  2. First we will calculate fn(75)mod 16. Note that if a, b are odd positive integers and a≡b mod 16, then aa≡bbmod 16. Also 33≡11 mod 16 and 1111≡3 mod 16. We now prove by induction on n that f2n-1(75)≡11 mod 16 for all n∈N. This is clear for n = 1 so suppose f2n-1(75)≡11 mod 16 and set k = f2n-1(75) and m = f2n(75). Then

    f2n(75)≡kk≡1111 ≡3 mod 16    
    f2n+1(75)≡mm≡33 ≡11 mod 16    

    and the induction step is complete. We now prove that fn(a)≡fn+2(a)mod 17 for all a, n∈N with a prime to 17 and n even. In fact we have

    fn+1(a)≡a3mod 17,    fn+2(a)≡(a3)11≡a mod 17.

    Thus f100(75)≡f2(75)mod 17. Therefore f100(75)≡711≡14 mod 17.

  3. First note the e2πi/7 satisfies 1 + x + ... + x6 = 0, so by taking the real part, we obtain ∑n=0n=6cos 2nπ/7 = 0. Since cos 2π/7 = cos 12π/7, cos 4π/7 = cos 10π/7 = - cos 3π/7 and cos 6π/7 = cos 8π/7 = - cosπ/7, we see that 1 - 2 cosπ/7 + 2 cos 2π/7 - 2 cos 3π/7 = 0.

    Observe that if 1 - 2 cosθ +2 cos 2θ -2 cos 3θ = 0, then by using cos 2θ = 2 cos2θ - 1 and cos 3θ = 4 cos3θ -3 cosθ, we find that cosθ satisfies 8x3 -4x2 - 4x + 1 = 0. Thus in particular cosπ/7 satisfies this equation. Next note that 1 - 2 cos 3π/7 + 2 cos 6π/7 - 2 cos 9π/7 = 1 - 2 cos 3π/7 - 2 cosπ/7 + 2 cos 2π/7, so cos 3π/7 is also a root of 8x3 -4x2 - 4x + 1. Finally since the sum of the roots of this equation is 1/2, we find that -cos 2θ is also a root. Thus the roots of 8x3 -4x2 - 4x + 1 are cosπ/7, -cos 2π/7, cos 3π/7.

  4. The equation 4A + 3C = 540o tells us that A = 3B. Let D on BC such that ∠ADC = 3B, and then let E on BD such that ∠AED = 2B.


    \begin{picture}(100,40)(-5,-3)
\put(0,0){\line(1,0){80}}
\put(60,0){\line(0,1){3...
...ut(60.6,.6){3B}
\scaleput(40,0){\arc(8.8,0){60}}
\put(42.3,.6){2B}
\end{picture}

    Since triangles ABD and AED are similar, we see that

    BD/AD = AD/ED = AB/AE.

    Also BE = AE because B = ∠BAE, and BE = BD - BE. We deduce that BD2 = AD2 + AB·AD. Since BD = BC - CD, we conclude that (BC - CD)2 = AD2 + AB·AD.

    Next triangles ABC and ADC are similar, consequently

    BC/AC = AB/AD = AC/CD.

    Thus AD = AB·AC/BC and CD = AC2/BC. We deduce that

    (a - b2/a)2 = c2b2/a2 + c2b/a.

    Therefore (a2 - b2)2 = bc2(a + b) and the result follows.

  5. Let X denote the center of A, let Y denote the center of B, let Z be where A and B touch (so X, Y, Z are collinear), and let θ = ∠PXY. Note that YQ makes an angle 2θ downwards with respect to the horizontal, because ∠QYZ = 3θ.


    \begin{picture}(110,52)(-4,5)
\put(40,30){\bigcircle{48}}
\put(53.9,38){\bigcirc...
...14.0, 37.2, 18.5, 44.0,
23.1, 51.3, 26.7, 57.9, 28.9, 62.4, 29.9)
\end{picture}

    Choose (x, y)-coordinates such that X is the origin and XP is on the line y = 0. Let (x, y) denote the coordinates of Q. Then we have

    x = 2 cosθ + cos 2θ    
    y = 2 sinθ - sin 2θ.    

    By symmetry the area above the x-axis equals the area below the x-axis (we don't really need this observation, but it may make things easier to follow). Also θ goes from 2π to 0 as circle B goes round circle A. Therefore the area enclosed by the locus of Q is

    2∫π0y(dx/dθ) dθ = 2∫π0(2 sinθ - sin 2θ)(- 2 sinθ -2 sin 2θ) dθ    
      = 2∫0π(4 sin2θ +2 sinθsin 2θ -2 sin22θ) dθ    
      = ∫0π(4 - 4 cos 2θ +2 cosθ -2 cos 3θ -2 + 2 cos 4θ) dθ = 2π.    

  6. Note that if 0 < x, y < 1, then 0 < 1 - y/2 < 1 and 0 < x(1 - y/2) < 1, and it follows that (an) is a positive monotone decreasing sequence consisting of numbers strictly less that 1. This sequence must have a limit z where 0≤z≤1. In particular an+2 - an+1 = anan+1/2 has limit 0, so limn-> ∞anan+1 = 0. It follows that z = 0.

    Set bn = 1/an. Then bn+2 = bn+1/(1 - an/2) = bn+1(1 + an/2 + O(an2)). Therefore bn+2 - bn+1 = bn+1(an/2 + O(an2)). Also

    an/an+1 = (1 - an-1/2)-1 = 1 + O(an)

    and we deduce that bn+2 - bn+1 = bn(1 + O(an))(an/2 + O(an2)). Therefore bn+2 - bn+1 = 1/2 + O(an). Thus given ε > 0, there exists N∈N such that | bn+1 - bn -1/2| < ε for all n > N. We deduce that if k is a positive integer, then | bn+k/k - bn/k - 1/2| < ε. Thus for k sufficiently large, | bn+k/(n + k) - 1/2| < 2ε. We conclude that limn-> ∞bn/n = 1/2 and hence limn-> ∞nan = 2.

  7. It will be sufficient to prove that ∑n=1∞n2/(1/a12 + ... +1/an2) is convergent. Note we may assume that (an) is monotonic decreasing, because rearranging the terms in series ∑an does not affect its convergence, whereas the terms of the above series become largest when (an) is monotonic decreasing. Next observe that if ∑n=1∞an = S, then an≤S/n for all positive integers n. Now consider (2n)2/(1/a12 + ... +1/a2n2). This is ≤(2n)2S/(1/a1 +2/a2 + ... +2n/a2n)≤4n2S/(n2/an) = 4San. The result follows.





Peter Linnell 2010-11-04